Ukraine crisis: Is Russia staging "false flag" incidents?

2 years ago 36
ARTICLE AD BOX

By Kayleen Devlin, Jake Horton and Olga Robinson
BBC Monitoring & Reality Check

Image source, Getty Images

Russian authorities have cited a number of incidents in eastern Ukraine in order to justify military action.

In his speech on Monday, Vladimir Putin said that the Ukrainian authorities "are not interested in a peaceful solution."

"On the contrary, they are trying to set up a blitzkrieg in Donbas," he said.

But the US has warned of Russia faking provocative acts - so-called "false flag" incidents which are staged to appear to come from one side in a conflict - in order to create a pretext for action.

So what has happened in eastern Ukraine and what do we know about it?

Alleged 'sabotage' of separatists

Among the rumours circulating on social media are a number of alleged attacks. For example, on Friday, a video circulated on a Telegram channel run by Russia-backed separatists. It claimed to show a clash between an "enemy sabotage group" and pro-Russian forces in eastern Ukraine.

The post said the video showed pro-Ukrainian militants trying to blow up a chlorine tank in the separatist-held area of Donbass.

"The armed formations of Ukraine are purposefully trying to sow fear and panic among the civilian population," the post claimed. "The above facts are direct confirmation of the preparations of the Ukrainian side to unleash hostilities."

The video was then picked up by pro-separatist and Russian news agencies.

But open source investigators on social media pointed out several discrepancies which indicated the video was shot at an earlier date and had been manipulated.

When inspecting the video's metadata - which can be used to see when a file was created or modified - investigators discovered it had a creation date of 8 February - ten days before it was posted.

The video also appears to have audio dubbed over it taken from a YouTube clip posted in 2010 of a military firing range in Finland. It looks highly unlikely that this video shows what the separatists claim it shows.

Donetsk evacuation

Other stories have created an impression of impending panic in the separatist areas.

Also on Friday, leaders of the two separatist areas called for a mass evacuation of residents, saying Ukraine had intensified hostilities and was planning further attacks.

Image source, YouTube

Image caption,

Denis Pushilin announced an 'emergency' evacuation of residents

Denis Pushilin, head of the self-proclaimed Donetsk People's Republic, published a video announcing the "emergency" evacuation.

At one point in the video Mr Pushilin says "today, on 18 February". But a BBC analysis of the metadata showed that rather being recorded in the heat of the moment, this video was also filmed in advance - two days earlier.

'Car bombing' in Donetsk

Russian state media also reported a "powerful explosion" in the centre of the city of Donetsk, near the separatist government headquarters.

Pro-Russian separatists alleged it was a car bombing and Denis Sinenkov, chief of the Donetsk separatist police, claimed the vehicle belonged to him. Russian media reported that nobody was hurt in the incident.

But questions have been raised about whether the attack was staged.

Russian journalist Anton Pustovalov tweeted that the number plate on the destroyed car was taken from a different vehicle - one the head of the separatist police was previously spotted using - in order to then say that a "terrorist attack was being launched against him".

Third. License plate.
A real car with the same license plate is used by the head of the Donetsk military police. It was about him that propaganda began to say that a terrorist attack was being launched against him.
A car with this number was spotted on May 31, 2021 pic.twitter.com/JwlOS22XEv

— Anton Pustovalov (@djxtrees) February 20, 2022

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites.View original tweet on Twitter

The BBC is unable to independently verify these claims. The Ukrainian government has denied several of the online rumours.

No, Ukraine did NOT:

❌Attack Donetsk or Luhansk
❌Send saboteurs or APCs over the Russian border
❌Shell Russian territory
❌Shell Russian border crossing
❌Conduct acts of sabotage

Ukraine also does NOT plan any such actions.

Russia, stop your fake-producing factory now.

— Dmytro Kuleba (@DmytroKuleba) February 21, 2022

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites.View original tweet on Twitter

'Ukrainian' vehicle

Questions have also been raised about some of the footage shown on Russian state TV as illustration of alleged Ukrainian acts of aggression.

The Russian military claimed on Monday that its forces had killed five members of a Ukrainian "saboteur group" and destroyed two armoured personnel vehicles following an alleged incursion into Russian territory.

Reporting from the site of the alleged clash, Channel One - one of Russia's most popular state TV channels - showed footage of what it described as one of the destroyed Ukrainian vehicles.

Image source, Channel One Russia/Youtube

Image caption,

The rear of the burned BR-70M vehicle broadcast on Russian state TV

But Sam Cranny-Evans, a research analyst at the defence think-tank RUSI, says there is "no compelling evidence to say it's a Ukrainian vehicle".

Both Ukrainians and Russians have produced the BTR-70 vehicles, Mr Cranny-Evans says, and there are different versions of it, but the one shown on Russian TV is similar to the version produced in Russia.

Experts with the Ukrainian military portal Militarnyy also said that the vehicle was the Russian version of BTR-70M, which has been produced at a plant in the Russian city of Arzamas since 2006.

Read Entire Article